Chapter 23 — REAL PROPERTY TRANSACTIONS›Article VI — LABOR REPRESENTATION PROCEDURES IN HOTEL AND RESTAURANT DEVELOPMENTS IN WHICH THE CITY HAS AN ONGOING PROPRIETARY INTEREST
SEC. 23.51. DEFINITIONS.
San Francisco Administrative Code · 2025 edition · updated 2026-07-25 · San Francisco
For purposes of this Article, the following definitions shall apply:
(1) "Card check agreement" means a written agreement between an employer and a labor organization providing a procedure for determining employee preference on the subject of whether to be represented by a labor organization for collective bargaining, and if so, by which labor organization to be represented, which provides, at a minimum, the following:
(a) Determining employee preference regarding union representation shall be by a card check procedure conducted by a neutral third party in lieu of a formal election;
(b) All disputes over interpretation or application of the parties' card check agreement, and over issues regarding how to carry out the card check process or specific card check procedures shall be submitted to binding arbitration;
(c) Forbearance by any labor organization from economic action against the employer at the worksite of an organizing drive covered by this Article, and in relation to an organizing campaign only (not to the terms of a collective bargaining agreement), so long as the employer complies with the terms of the card check agreement;
(d) Language and procedures prohibiting the labor organization or the employer from coercing or intimidating employees, explicitly or implicitly, in selecting or not selecting a bargaining representative.
(2) "City contract" means a Lease, management agreement, service agreement, loan, bond, guarantee, or other similar agreement to which the City is a party and in which the City has a proprietary interest.
(3) "Collective bargaining agreement" means an agreement between an employer and a labor organization regarding wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment of the employer's employees. For purposes of this Article, a collective bargaining agreement does not include a card check agreement as defined herein.
(4) "Developer" means any person, corporation, association, general or limited partnership, limited liability company, joint venture or other entity which does or which proposes to purchase, Lease, develop, build, remodel or otherwise establish a hotel or restaurant project.
(5) "Economic action" means concerted action initiated or conducted by a labor union and/or employees acting in concert therewith, to bring economic pressure to bear against an employer, as part of a campaign to organize employees or prospective employees of that employer, including such activities as striking, picketing, or boycotting. A lawsuit to enforce this Article is not "economic action."
(6) "Employer" means any developer, manager/operator or subcontractor who employs individuals in a hotel or restaurant in a hotel or restaurant project.
(7) "Hotel or restaurant project" means a development project or facility in which the City has a proprietary interest and which contains a hotel or restaurant. For purposes herein a "hotel" shall mean any use or facility falling within either definition of Section 314.1(g) or (h) of the San Francisco Planning Code. For purposes herein a "restaurant" shall mean any facility that has as its principal purpose the sale of food and beverage for primarily on-site consumption, including any such facility operating within or as part of another facility, such as a stadium, hotel or retail store. A hotel or restaurant project, as defined herein, includes a mixed-use development project in which the City has a proprietary interest which contains a hotel or restaurant, regardless of whether the City's proprietary interest is in the hotel or restaurant portion of such mixed-use development or the mixed-use development project as a whole. Notwithstanding the foregoing or anything else contained herein, the requirement in this Article that an employer enter into a card check agreement shall apply only to those employers who employ employees in a hotel or restaurant and shall not apply to those portions of a mixed-use development project which do not contain a hotel or restaurant.
(8) "Labor organization" means any organization of any kind, or any agency or employee representation committee or plan, in which employees participate and which exists for the purpose, in whole or in part, of dealing with employers concerning grievances, labor disputes, wages, rates of pay, hours of employment, or conditions of work.
(9) "Manager/operator" means any person, corporation, association, limited or general partnership, joint venture or other entity (including a developer) that operates or manages a hotel or restaurant in a hotel or restaurant project, or provides any material portion of the services provided by such hotel or restaurant in a hotel or restaurant project, whether by subcontract or City contract.
(10) "Proprietary interest" means any nonregulatory arrangement or circumstance in which the financial or other nonregulatory interests of the City in a hotel or restaurant project could be adversely affected by labor/management conflict or consumer boycotts potentially resulting from a union organizing campaign, in the following circumstances:
(i) The City receives significant ongoing revenue (such as rent payments) under a Lease of Real Property owned by the City for the development of a hotel or restaurant project, excluding government fees or tax or assessment revenues, or the like (except for tax revenues under the circumstances specified in (ii)); or
(ii) The City receives ongoing revenue from a hotel or restaurant project to pay debt service on bonds or loans provided by the City to assist the development of such hotel or restaurant project (including incremental tax revenues generated by the hotel or restaurant project or the development project in which it is located and used, directly or indirectly, to pay debt service on bonds or to repay a loan by the City where the proceeds are used for development of that hotel or restaurant project or the development project in which it is located);
(iii) The City has agreed to underwrite or guarantee the development or operation of a hotel or restaurant project, or loans related thereto.
In addition to the circumstances described in (i)above, the City shall be deemed to have a proprietary interest in a hotel or restaurant project if the City determines or an interested party demonstrates prior to the effective date of the subcontract or City contract pursuant to which a hotel or restaurant will be operated in a hotel or restaurant project that there is a significant risk that the City's financial or other nonregulatory interest in a hotel or restaurant project could be adversely affected by labor/management conflict or consumer boycotts potentially resulting from a union organizing campaign except that no circumstance or arrangement shall be considered "financial or non-regulatory" under this definition if it is such that arises from the exercise of regulatory or police powers such as taxation, (except as provided in (ii) above), zoning or the issuance of permits and licenses.
(11) "Subcontract" means any Lease, sublease, management agreement or other similar agreement between a developer or a manager/operator and a subcontractor which contemplates or permits the subcontractor to operate or manage all or a portion of a hotel or restaurant in a hotel or restaurant project.
(12) "Subcontractor" means any person, corporation, association, limited or general partnership, limited liability company, joint venture or other entity that enters into a subcontract with a developer or manager/operator.
(13) "Substantial amendment" to a Pre-Existing Agreement, for purposes of the exemption for Employers operating before the effective date of this Chapter in Section 23.53(b)(2) and Section Two of Ordinance No. 108-99, means an amendment to or renewal or extension of a Pre-Existing Agreement that provides for or permits any of the following:
(a) A change in use within the scope of this Article (i.e., which provides for the operation of a hotel or restaurant);
(b) An increase in square footage, seating or rooms of more than 25%; except neither of the following, by themselves, shall constitute a substantial amendment:
(i) Addition of outside seating or patio dining which increases the total seating or square footage devoted to seating by less than 25%;
(ii) An increase in space for purpose of parking or storage; or
(c) A new Lease period of greater duration than the period provided in the Pre-Existing Agreement.
(Formerly Sec. 23.32; added by Ord. 6-98, App. 1/16/98; amended by Ord. 108-99, File No. 990298, App. 5/7/99; amended and renumbered by Ord. 15-01, File No. 001965, App. 2/2/2001)
Get a plain-English answer with a citation back to this text.
Ask AI about this code▸ Contents — San Francisco Administrative Code
- Chapter 1 — GENERAL PROVISIONS
- Chapter 2 — BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
- Chapter 2A — EXECUTIVE BRANCH
- Chapter 2B
- Chapter 3 — BUDGET PROCEDURES
- Chapter 4 — CITY BUILDINGS E UIPMENT AND VEHICLES , Q,
- Chapter 5 — COMMITTEES
- Chapter 6 — PUBLIC WORKS CONTRACTING POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
- Chapter 7 — DISASTER COUNCIL
- Chapter 8 — DOCUMENTS RECORDS AND PUBLICATIONS ,
- Chapter 9A — FARMERS' MARKET
- Chapter 9B — FLEA MARKET
- Chapter 10 — FINANCE TAXATION AND OTHER FISCAL MATTERS ,,
- Chapter 10A — [REQUEST FOR SHERIFF’S SERVICES]
- Chapter 10B — SPECIAL LAW ENFORCEMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS SERVICES
- Chapter 10C — REIMBURSEMENT FOR TOWING AND STORAGE OF VEHICLES
- Chapter 10D — [RESERVED] CHAPTER 10E: PLANNING MONITORING
- Chapter 10F
- Chapter 10G
- Chapter 10H — RECOVERY OF COSTS OF EMERGENCY RESPONSE
- Chapter 11 — FRANCHISES
- Chapter 12 — HOUSING AUTHORITY
- Chapter 12A
- Chapter 12B — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12C — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12D — MINORITY/WOMEN/LOCAL BUSINESS UTILIZATION
- Chapter 12E — BAN ON CITY USE OF GAS-POWERED LANDSCAPING EQUIP…
- Chapter 12F — IMPLEMENTING THE MACBRIDE PRINCIPLES – NORTHERN …
- Chapter 12G — PROHIBITION ON USE OF PUBLIC FUNDS FOR POLITICAL…
- Chapter 12H — IMMIGRATION STATUS
- Chapter 12I — CIVIL IMMIGRATION DETAINERS
- Chapter 12J — CITY BUSINESS WITH BURMA PROHIBITED
- Chapter 12K — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12L
- Chapter 12M
- Chapter 12N — LESBIAN, GAY, BISEXUAL, TRANSGENDER, QUEER, AND …
- Chapter 12O — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12P — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12Q — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12R — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12S — WORKING FAMILIES CREDIT PROGRAM
- Chapter 12T — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12U
- Chapter 12V — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 12W — [REDESIGNATED] 1
- Chapter 12X — [REPEALED]
- Chapter 12Y
- Chapter 12Z — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 13 — JAILS AND PRISONERS
- Chapter 14 — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 14A — DISADVANTAGED BUSINESS ENTERPRISE PROGRAM
- Chapter 14B — LOCAL BUSINESS ENTERPRISE UTILIZATION AND NON-DI…
- Chapter 14C — [EXPIRED]
- Chapter 15 — MENTAL HEALTH SERVICE
- Chapter 16 — OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES GENERALLY
- Chapter 17 — PUBLIC OFF-STREET PARKING FACILITIES
- Chapter 18 — PAYROLL PROCEDURE
- Chapter 19 — PUBLIC SAFETY CAMERA ORDINANCE
- Chapter 19A — PUBLIC HEALTH
- Chapter 19B — ACQUISITION OF SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
- Chapter 20 — SOCIAL SERVICES
- Chapter 21 — ACQUISITION OF COMMODITIES AND SERVICES
- Chapter 21A — HEALTH-RELATED COMMODITIES AND SERVICES
- Chapter 21B — CORE INITIATIVES ADDRESSING HOMELESSNESS, DRUG O…
- Chapter 21C — [REDESIGNATED]
- Chapter 21D — FOOD PURCHASES AT HOSPITALS OPERATED BY THE DEPA…
- Chapter 21E — GOODS OR SERVICES CONTRACTS FOR INCARCERATED PER…
- Chapter 21F — SAN FRANCISCO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION SOCIAL…
- Chapter 21G
- Chapter 21H — PROCUREMENT OF FIREARMS AND AMMUNITION
- Chapter 22 — RADIO COMMUNICATION FACILITIES
- Chapter 22A — INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY
- Chapter 22B — TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES
- Chapter 22C — PUBLIC INTERNET ACCESS
- Chapter 22D — OPEN DATA POLICY
- Chapter 22E — CITY-OWNED FIBER-OPTIC FACILITIES
- Chapter 22G — OFFICE OF EMERGING TECHNOLOGY
- Chapter 22H — DESIGNATION UNDER HEALTH INSURANCE PORTABILITY A…
- Chapter 22I — OFFICE OF CYBER SECURITY AND DUTIES OF THE CHIEF…
- Chapter 22J — ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE TOOLS
-
▸ Chapter 23 — REAL PROPERTY TRANSACTIONS
Overview- SEC. 23.1. DIRECTOR OF PROPERTY TO CONDUCT SALES, LEASES, ACCE…
- SEC. 23.2. CHAPTER DEFINITIONS.
- SEC. 23.3. CONVEYANCE AND ACQUISITION OF REAL PROPERTY.
- SEC. 23.4. ACCEPTANCE OF DEEDS BY DIRECTOR OF PROPERTY AND ASS…
- SEC. 23.5. EXPENSES OF REAL ESTATE DEPARTMENT IN CONNECTION WI…
- SEC. 23.6. SALE OR LEASE OF PUBLIC UTILITY PROPERTY.
- SEC. 23.7. PUBLIC NOTICE REQUIRED PRIOR TO BOARD OF SUPERVISOR…
- SEC. 23.8. ANNUAL REAL PROPERTY REPORTING AND PLANNING.
- SEC. 23.9. GOVERNMENT ENTITY AGREEMENTS.
- Article II — INTERDEPARTMENTAL TRANSFER OF REAL PROPERTY
- Article III — LEASES WHEN CITY IS TENANT
- Article IV — LEASES WHEN CITY IS LANDLORD
- Article V
-
▸ Article VI — LABOR REPRESENTATION PROCEDURES IN HOTEL AND REST…
- Article VII — PREVAILING WAGE, APPRENTICESHIP, AND LOCAL HIRE …
- Article VIII — MINIMIZING LABOR/MANAGEMENT CONFLICT IN PORT LE…
- Chapter 23A — SURPLUS PUBLIC LANDS ORDINANCE
- Chapter 24 — REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
- Chapter 24A — ADMINISTRATIVE STRUCTURE LOCAL RENT SUPPLEMENT P…
- Chapter 24B — RELOCATION APPEALS BOARD
- Chapter 25 — STREET LIGHTING
- Chapter 26 — [RESERVED]
- Chapter 27 — HEALTHY NAIL SALON RECOGNITION PROGRAM
- Chapter 28 — ADMINISTRATIVE DEBARMENT PROCEDURE
- Chapter 29 — FINDINGS OF FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY AND FEASIBILITY
- Chapter 29A — APPROVAL OF POWER PLANT PLANNING CODE SEC. 303 C…
- Chapter 29B — CHILD CARE FEASIBILITY STUDY FOR CITY AND CITY-F…
- Chapter 30 — CENTRALIZATION OF WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
- Chapter 31 — CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT PROCEDURES A…
- Chapter 32 — RESIDENTIAL REHABILITATION LOAN PROGRAM
- Chapter 33 — COMMISSION ON THE STATUS OF WOMEN
- Chapter 33A — LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION OF THE UNITED NATIONS CONVE…
- Chapter 34 — NOTIFICATION TO ASSESSOR CONCERNING ZONING RECLAS…
- Chapter 35 — RESIDENTIAL HOTEL AND PDR COMPATIBILITY AND PROTE…
- Chapter 36 — COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENTS AREA PLANS AND PROGRAMS
- Chapter 37 — RESIDENTIAL RENT STABILIZATION AND ARBITRATION OR…
- Chapter 37A — RENT STABILIZATION AND ARBITRATION FEE
- Chapter 37B — MIDTOWN PARK APARTMENTS
- Chapter 37C — [EXPIRED]
- Chapter 38 — COMMERCIAL LANDLORDS; ACCESS IMPROVEMENT OBLIGATI…
- Chapter 39 — [RIGHT TO RETURN TO REVITALIZED PUBLIC HOUSING]
- Chapter 40 — HOUSING CODE ENFORCEMENT LOAN PROGRAM
- Chapter 41 — RESIDENTIAL HOTEL UNIT CONVERSION AND DEMOLITION
- Chapter 41A — RESIDENTIAL UNIT CONVERSION AND DEMOLITION
- Chapter 41B — COMMUNITY OPPORTUNITY TO PURCHASE ACT
- Chapter 41C — TIME-SHARE CONVERSION ORDINANCE
- Chapter 41D — RESIDENTIAL HOTEL VISITOR POLICIES
- Chapter 41E — RESIDENTIAL HOTEL MAIL RECEPTACLE ORDINANCE
- Chapter 41F
- Chapter 41G — RESIDENTIAL HOTEL COVID-19 PROTECTIONS
- Chapter 41H — [EXPIRED]
- Chapter 42 — INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
- Chapter 43 — MUNICIPAL FINANCE LAW
- Title 1 — GENERAL PROVISIONS AND DEFINITIONS SEC. 43.1.1. TITLE.
- Title 2 — FINANCING RESIDENCES SEC. 43.1.7. LOANS FOR RESIDENC…
- Title 3 — BONDS
- Title 4 — SUPPLEMENTAL PROVISIONS
- Title 1 — GENERAL PROVISIONS AND DEFINITIONS SEC. 43.2.1. TITLE.
- Title 2 — FINANCING FACILITIES
- Title 3 — BONDS SEC. 43.2.17. ISSUANCE OF BONDS.
- Title 4 — SUPPLEMENTAL PROVISIONS SEC. 43.2.27. LIBERAL CONSTR…
- Title 1 — GENERAL PROVISIONS SEC. 43.10.1. TITLE.
- Title 2 — PROVISIONS RELATING TO FORMATION OF DISTRICTS SEC. 4…
- Title 3 — PROVISIONS RELATING TO BONDS SEC. 43.10.18. ALTERNAT…
- Title 4 — SUPPLEMENTAL PROVISIONS SEC. 43.10.22. LIBERAL CONST…
- Title 5 — CHANGE PROCEEDINGS SEC. 43.10.26. ALTERNATE PROCEDUR…
- Title 1 — GENERAL PROVISIONS AND DEFINITIONS SEC. 43.15.1. TIT…
- Title 2 — RESIDENCES SEC. 43.15.6. LOANS TO QUALIFIED 501(c)(3…
- Title 3 — BONDS SEC. 43.15.15. ISSUANCE OF BONDS; LOANS TO QUA…
- Title 4 — SUPPLEMENTAL PROVISIONS SEC. 43.15.25. LIBERAL CONST…